Mennonites Meet With President Roosevelt

Written Spring of 2010

I recently read again a book my father treasured, The Franconia Mennonites and War by Willard Hunsberger.  Many years before when I had looked at it, I had been sitting with my dad and he had pointed out men that I knew that had served at various Civilian Public Service (CPS) camps during WWII. Now, seven years after my dad’s death, I was looking at it again in a new way.  It was written in 1951 when the historical facts of World War II were still easily remembered and dedicated to John E. Lapp “who first conceived the idea of this volume.” Just as in 1951 “it is important that the rising generation be reminded of the faith of our fathers who were willing to leave home and country to maintain a good conscience.”

I didn’t realize the extent of the Mennonite church’s political involvement leading up to WW II, in 1937-1940. During that time, Mennonite church leaders wrote resolutions stating the Mennonite’s convictions regarding war and even met with President Roosevelt on more than one occasion.  Along with the Church of the Brethren and Society of Friends, the Mennonites continued to advocate a place of recognition for their young men that had a conscience against the “destruction of human life.” Orie Miller (pictured above on the National Service Board for Religious Objectors [NSBRO]), Harold S Bender, and E L. Harshbarger were just a few of the Mennonite leaders that worked tirelessly during this time period by traveling to Washington DC and presenting proposals that outlined the foreign relief, mental and medical health projects, and reforestry work that could be accomplished in CPS camps. But the actual 1940 presidential approval came only after the Mennonite Church agreed to finance the CPS camps and the men. 

In our Franconia Conference, a Peace Problems Committee of John E. Lapp, Jacob M. Moyer, and Jacob C. Clemens was formed.  “To aid in teaching nonresistance and to impress upon the people the urgency of the situation, the committee arranged for a Nonresistance Conference for September 3 and 4, 1939, which was held at Souderton Church.”  After President Roosevelt signed the Burke-Wadsworth Conscription Act,  making it law that all male residents between the ages of 21 and 35 register with their local draft board, this committee was on constant call, assisting registrants in filling out questionnaires, interviewing draft boards, and advising young men of draft age.  Many men from Franconia Conference benefited from the cordial relationship between the draft boards in Lansdale and Doylestown and the peace committee members, particularly John Lapp.  John helped many men navigate the unfamiliar world of Selective Service Law and draft board members that questioned their sincerity.  

These men had an immense support from their churches when they took that step of proclaiming their conscientious objection to war.

See for more information.

One thought on “Mennonites Meet With President Roosevelt

  1. Pingback: “Dispelling Mennonite myths at Kutztown Folk Festival” | Pennsylvania Mental Health Issues

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s